Categories to Explore

Halloween Caprese Eyeballs

 Halloween Caprese Eyeballs

What are your Halloween plans? Whether you’re headed to a fun adult costume party, a kids trick or treat event, or just hanging out at home, these Halloween Caprese Eyeballs are the perfect way to get you in the spirit… without all the usual sugar and preservatives that comes with Halloween treats.

Bonus: if you really enjoy grossing out to the max, the pesto gives the ghoulish illusion of infected eyeballs! Keep reading for step-by-step instructions on how to make these deliciously festive appetizers.


This post was sponsored by Sprouts Farmers Market.

All thoughts, opinions, and ideas are my own.

Halloween Caprese Eyeballs

12 small tomatoes

Sprouts Organic Pesto Sauce

8oz. whipped cream cheese

Sliced black olives

Fresh Basil

Using a sharp knife, cut each of the tomatoes in half. Carefully spoon out the insides of the tomatoes and discard, saving the skins as shown.


Next, empty the pesto sauce into a squirt bottle. (I found a great one at my local dollar store. See picture). Squirt pesto on the rim of the tomato skins as shown.


Fill each tomato skin with cream cheese. It’s ok if things start to get a little messy and the pesto spreads into the cream cheese. This gives the illusion of “infected” eyeballs!

Next, press a sliced black olive into the center of each eyeball. Using the squirt bottle, squirt a small amount of pesto in the middle of each olive.

Finally place 1 or 2 eyeballs over a large basil leaf and skewer with a toothpick. Enjoy!


More to explore...

orange juice and grape popsicles for halloween

Homemade Black Grape Popsicles for Halloween

I don’t know about you, but Halloween is usually still pretty hot around here, so I’ve whipped up some deliciously spooky Halloween themed grape popsicles to celebrate!

low sugar gluten free apple crisp

Low Sugar Gluten Free Apple Crisp

My low sugar gluten free apple crisp recipe is so simple to make and loaded with delicious seasonal apple flavor!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

tame sugar demons!

By entering your email below, you agree to receive emails about new resources and events from Milk & Honey Nutrition.

This site uses cookies to help improve your user experience. You acknowledge your acceptance by clicking Accept. Read our Privacy Policy here.